The Ringleader

Lieutenant Colonel James L. McAvity
26th (New Brunswick) BattalionMcAvity

“Actual demonstration of the wonderful ability of the Overland cars in the rear of the trenches of the allied nations caused me to buy an Overland.” said Colonel McAvity, 26th Battalion, St. John, N.B., Just after one of the new Overland models was delivered to him by J. A. Pugnley, Overland dealer at St. John. Colonel McAvity recently returned home on a short furlough, and in order to get the most out of his, brief leave of absence purchased a motor car.

(Ottawa Journal, 26 August 1916, 13)

James Lupton McAvity was born on 8 October 1867 in Saint John, New Brunswick. He began his career with the family manufacturing business, T. McAvity & Sons Ltd. in the mid-1880s. His position as a company manager and representative took him to western Canada, Chicago and New York. During the gold rush of 1897, he traveled to Alaska and the Yukon in search of his fortune.

As commanding officer of the 62nd Fusiliers Regiment, McAvity organized the 26th Battalion from New Brunswick in spring 1915. The 26th deployed to France in September 1915 as part of the 5th Infantry Brigade in the 2nd Division. Suffering from gastritis and insomnia, McAvity began displaying nervous symptoms, tremors and fidgeting. On 29 May 1916, Major A. E. G. McKenzie took over the 26th and McAvity returned home that summer.

In spring 1919, while in command of the 1st New Brunswick Depot Battalion at Camp Sussex, McAvity and several officers came under a cloud of scandal. Suspicions over a shortage of canteen funds led military officials to charge the colonel and his staff with conspiring to defraud the battalion.

On 2 May 1919, authorities arrested McAvity along with his alleged conspiracy ring of Major F. H. Rowe, Captains G. Earle Logan and R. Ingleton, Lieutenants Stockwell, Simms and Belyea and Sergeant-Major Rawlings. During the court-martial proceedings, McAvity denied any knowledge of the fraud and claimed to have reimbursed the battalion out of his own pocket. General Archibald H. Macdonell, formerly of the 5th Brigade, testified to the good character of the defendant, asserting that McAvity would never do anything dishonourable.

The court martial board, presided by Brigadier General V. A. S. Williams, handed down its decision on 10 June. Major Rowe was severely reprimanded. Captain Logan was dismissed from the service. Rawlings was demoted. Lieutenant Belyea received a six-month prison sentence. As the supposed ringleader of this nefarious cabal, McAvity was cashiered.

He died in St. John on 1 November 1932.

RG 150, Accession 1992-93/166, Box 6587 – 44


Image: Overland Advertisement, Canada Monthly, Nov 1915, 58

4 thoughts on “The Ringleader

  1. Would like to know your sources. I was not under the impression that McAvity was considered – let alone labeled – “ringleader” in the canteen embezzlement.

  2. Hi Greg,

    The 1919 Canadian Annual Review (p. 26) had a neat summary of the case. The Ottawa Journal also reported on the court martial- for instance: “St. John Officers are Under Arrest” (2 May 1919, p.17); “St. John Canteen Graft Due to Carelessness” (14 May 1919, p. 16); “Accused on Stand in St. John Enquiry: McAvity Paid Canteen Shortage Because He Felt Responsibility” (15 May 1919, p. 18).

    Was McAvity the chief conspirator to defraud the battalion? Probably not. Was he the leading figure in a cover-up by reimbursing the canteen? Maybe. As for the title “Ringleader,” my site is occasionally tongue-in-cheek (or as far as a website about CEF colonels can be tongue-in-cheek).

    If you have access to further information about McAvity or especially his court martial- I would be very excited to know! Thanks for reading!

    • Such a sad end to LCol McAvity’s story. He never got over the shame of being cashiered. The government made him return his medals. He died by suicide, shot himself, in 1932.

      A tragic end for the man who had raised such a fine Battalion as the Fighting 26th.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s