The Troublemakers

Lieutenant Colonel W. H. Allen
Lieutenant Colonel Robert Innes
106th (Nova Scotia Rifles) BattalionInnes

A fellow works his heart and soul out to recruit and organize a Battalion, brings it across here with the expectation of taking it to the front, has it taken away without even a “thank-you” and is then told that he must revert, or go back to Canada. A just reward for his efforts!

(Innes to McCurdy, MP, 8 Nov 1916)

Born on 1 April 1882 in Kidderminster, England, Walter Henry Allen was a Nova Scotia carriage builder and Boer War veteran. He had enlisted as a captain with the 17th Battalion in September 1914 and fought with the 15th Battalion in France. After being wounded, Allen was authorized to raise the 106th in November 1915. Six months later, Allen was brought before a court martial board for ” behaving in a scandalous manner, unbecoming the character of an officer and a gentleman.” He was cashiered and replaced by Robert Innes, a twenty-four year old major. Born on 18 August 1891 in Colbrook, Nova Scotia, Innes held a degree in scientific agriculture and had served for several years in the militia.

Although many Canadian recruiters had discouraged the enlistment of black volunteers, in 1915 the 106th Battalion’s first commander, Lieutenant Colonel Allen, asserted, “coloured men should do their share in the Empire’s defence.” Allen was nevertheless wary of black volunteers serving alongside white soldiers. He appealed for Reverend William White to a raise a black platoon, but the Militia Department ordered no distinction for units based on skin colour. In total, the 106th recruited sixteen black soldiers, including Private Jeremiah Jones, who eventually received official recognition for distinguished service at Vimy Ridge.

106thTo Innes’ great disappointment, the 106th was broken up upon arriving in England. He related his “tale of woe” to Nova Scotia MP Fleming McCurdy and complained that “our fate had been pre-arranged by some one.”

Feeling that Nova Scotians had been discriminated against by military authorities, Innes asserted, “I am willing to do anything, or go anywhere so long as I can hold my rank, and get fair play.”

Meanwhile, Canadian High Commissioner George Perley confided to Prime Minister Borden, “There has been considerable trouble about this officer.” Although military authorities “were not very favourably impressed with his attitude,” Innes eventually reverted to lieutenant in order to serve in France.

After seeing action at Vimy Ridge and Lens with the 87th Canadian Grenadier Guards, he was invalided to Canada. In 1918 he was appointed director of soldier settlement and colonization for Ontario. Innes later became deputy minister of agriculture of Nova Scotia. He died in 1960 at the age of sixty-nine.

Allen, Digitized Service File:

Innes, RG 150, Accession 1992-93/166, Box 4701 – 36

One thought on “The Troublemakers

  1. Pingback: Lt. Col. Allen, Part III | World War Graphic History

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s