The Americanist

Lieutenant Colonel P. A. Guthrie, M.P.P.
236th (Sir Sam’s Own) BattalionGuthrie

I do confess to be a Christian, but I must confess that when the time comes and we have the chance to even up old scores, I want to see their [German] towns leveled with the earth; I want to see their farmhouses in smoke; I want to see their land laid waste and desolate; and I want to see them fleeing before fire, sword and hate…

If I can but see this and help it on its way I will be happy to fall in the rush of victory…

(Boston Globe, 6 Jan 1918, 15)

Born on 20 June 1884 in Oromocto, New Brunswick, Percy Albert Guthrie was an Orangeman and Conservative member of the provincial legislature. He was one of the first volunteers to join the Canadian Expeditionary Force and sailed to England with Lieutenant Colonel Harry McLeod’s 12th Battalion. He fought with the 10th Battalion at Second Ypres and was seriously wounded by a shell explosion at Festubert on 25 May 1915.

236thGuthrie was invalided to Canada onboard the RMS Hesperian but a German U-boat torpedoed the ocean liner off the coast of Queenstown, Ireland. Trapped in his bed due to his injuries, Guthrie repeated the Lord’s Prayer and resigned himself to drowning. Fortunately, another wounded man managed to rescue him before the ship went down.

Once back in Canada, Guthrie proposed to raise a Scottish Highland Battalion based in the Maritimes. General Hugh Havelock McLean, Liberal MP and one of the most prominent military officers in New Brunswick, sponsored the battalion as the honorary colonel.

Guthrie sought recruits from across Canada as well as communities in New England. Through the cooperation of Boston Mayor Curley and other American politicians, over half of the 236th Battalion came from the United States. In recognition of the unit’s new composition, the officers decided on the name “McLean’s Kilties of America.” With its ranks filled, the 236th sailed for England where it was absorbed by the 20th Reserve Battalion in November 1917. Guthrie transferred to the Imperial Forces.

In 1919, Guthrie returned to a hero’s welcome in Boston where he stayed to practice law and become an American citizen. At the outbreak of the Second World War, he went to Montreal and tried to enlist as a private. However, the recruiting officers recognized the fifty-eight year old former colonel. Guthrie explained to the press, “I am not looking for any favors on account of my past services. I simply… came here to see if I could help in the fight Canada is waging for human freedom.” He was permitted to join the Veteran’s Guard.

Guthrie died in Norwell, Massachusetts on 25 April 1948.

Digitized Service File (LAC):


2 thoughts on “The Americanist

  1. Reblogged this on Ok, This One Time and commented:
    There are a couple of other people’s blogs that I read on here fairly regularly, and of course I’m always browsing for new ones. Quite some time ago now, I stumbled across one that I find very interesting called Patriots, Crooks, and Safety-Firsters. Its a blog about the Colonels of the Canadian Expeditionary Force in World War One. It’s update quite often, and being the history enthusiast that I am, I quite enjoy reading it. If you enjoy Canadian military history, you should check it out too.

    A while back there was a particular Colonel that caught my eye. As regular reader (aka, my mom and dad) might know, my fiancee lives in Boston for law school, and I am still in Saskatchewan, but trying to move there. Since she’s moved, I’ve started to try and learn more about history related to Boston, and I’m always delighted to learn something new. What makes this Colonel, Percy Albert Guthrie, so engaging for me is a unique connection to Boston (and as an added bonus for me, a connection to Boston lawyers). I’ll let you read it yourself, as I’ve re-blogged the post here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s